Nepal

KATHMANDU, FEBRUARY 19President Bidhya Devi Bhandari's move to provide blanket amnesty to all the local level candidates who were fined for not submitting the poll expenditure details within the deadline by the Election Commission (EC) has drawn flak from lawyers. President's amnesty move draws flak Presidential elections by February 11: EC It is a rare case where a President has waived fines on persons, although there is a practice of commuting or waiving the sentences of prisoners.

By doing so, hasn't the President undermined the independence of the judiciary, given that the case is subjudice. On Wednesday, the constitutional bench of the Supreme Court had stayed the EC decision to slap hefty fines on candidates on a writ petition filed by the Mayor of Kathmandu Metropolitan City (KMC) Balen Shah.

In the petition, he had demanded that Sections 26 (3) and 26 (5) of the Election Commission Act, which have given powers to the EC to take punitive action against the candidates, be declared null and void as they contradict the constitution.

Now that the President has granted amnesty to all erring local level candidates, the question remains, is it necessary for the apex court to give a verdict on the case?The EC had imposed blanket fines on 123,624 candidates.

They included 114,958 candidates who did not submit their election expenditure at all as well as 8,666 candidates who had submitted their poll expenditure details within the deadline.

KMC's Mayor claims he had submitted his expenditure details within the stipulated timeframe.

However, there were 136 candidates who had paid the fines amounting to Rs 45 million.

They did so because, as per the act, the EC can bar candidates who fail to submit the fines within six months from contesting the elections for the next six years.

It thus remains to be seen if the fines they have paid will be returned as the President has granted pardon to the candidates who have yet to pay the fines, as per the recommendation of the Cabinet meeting held on Thursday, but "makes no mention about those who have paid them already".The fines are rather steep, with mayoral candidates slapped a hefty Rs 750, 000 for not submitting the poll expenditures on time – an amount equal to the expenditure ceiling approved by the EC.

If the EC had gotten its way, it would have collected fines worth an astronomical 24 billion rupees.

This begs the question, why the difference in the fine between a local level candidate and a provincial assembly or federal parliamentary candidate? Thus, the laws regarding the fines for the local level candidates are not just and need a rethink.

After all, the candidates have not committed a heinous crime or one involving moral turpitude.

Some dalit candidates, who were living in squatter settlements, have said that they simply cannot pay the fines.

Also, one can vouch for it that no candidate has given the exact expenditure details, as it is not possible to contest an election within the expenditure ceiling fixed by the EC.

The submission of the expenditure details is no more than formality and doesn't help curb the huge expenses that go into the poll campaigns.

However, no matter how unfair the laws, the candidates should have been aware and abided by them as the common people learn from and imitate their leaders.Following the pardon, is it necessary for the apex court to give a verdict on the case?A version of this article appears in the print on February 20, 2023, of The Himalayan Times. .

This article first appeared/also appeared in https://thehimalayantimes.com 





Unlimited Portal Access + Monthly Magazine - 12 issues-Publication from Jan 2021


Buy Our Merchandise (Peace Series)

 


Contribute US to Start Broadcasting



It's Voluntary! Take care of your Family, Friends and People around You First and later think about us. Its Fine if you dont wish to contribute and if you wish to contribute then think about the Homeless first and Feed them. We can survive with your wishes too :-). You can Buy our Merchandise too which are of the finest quality.

Debit/Credit/UPI

UPI/Debit/Credit

Paytm


STRIPE


Construction of Mahakali Bridge resumes after five months


FM Shrestha holds meeting with Chinese counterpart Wang Yi


[Nepal] - Aarti Hamal, daughter of Mayor of Dhangadhi Gopal Hamal, has actually gone missing out on from Goa, India


INTERVIEW: Astronaut Ruben F. Salinas eyes Everest summit before suborbital spaceflight


UK court orders to delay extradition of WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange to US on espionage charges


APF to mobilize a unit of its platoon on 24-hour border patrol


Govt at work for prosperity: Chair Nepal


Changing political trend in Germany: Rise of right-extremism


Isarel begins distributing the amp;#039;terror victims allowance amp;#039; to the deceased amp;#039;s family


SC orders affiliation for B -C college to offer medical courses


Nepali nationals in Portugal to receive passport services


What is Holi, the Hindu festival of colors and how is it celebrated


Season amp;#039;s first Everest permit issued; Icefall doctors fixing route below Camp I


Indian toddler climbs Everest base camp as trekkers increase in Nepal


DPM Shrestha in Beijing


Five killed, three injured in Achham tractor accident


[Nepal] - -# 039; Mithila Mahakumbha -# 039; to conclude today


Holi celebrations sweep across Tarai region today


World Tuberculosis Day: Prevention Campaign in Baglung


[Nepal] - Just 27pc population has access to pure drinking water


Rain to continue for three more days


Japan hands over sanitary napkin making machine in Parsa


Lumbini is the fountain of Buddhism, DPM Shrestha says


Recording of statement with leader Mahara complete


World Happiness Report places Nepal in 93rd ranking


Home Ministry issues 21-point directives


[Nepal] - Humanitarian Staging Location to be built in Pokhara


[Nepal] - Japan turn over training center, emergency shelter in Rautahat


In memory of mountaineering legend David Breashears


96pc children vaccinated against measles, rubella


Govt waives climbing royalty for Nepal-Korea Friendship Expedition


[Nepal] - Nepal -# 039; s billionaire Binod Chaudhary under CIB scanner over land grab scandal


DNA tests of relatives ongoing to ascertain identity of Nepalis killed in Russia-Ukraine war


[Nepal] - The Asia Structure releases - Formative Research on Kid Trafficking in Nepal


Ridi-Tamghas route to remain closed for three weeks


7SF hands over insurance premium of Icefall Doctors to SPCC


DAOs instructed to place facilitation desk to hear usury victims amp;#039; problems


Long-neglected school building in Bajura to get new life


[Nepal] - Archeological study reveals hints of early malaria, 7th century chaang in Upper Mustang


[Nepal] - Conclave on Global Peace for Success in Lumbini


Govt to make diplomatic efforts to claim Nepali territory


No compromise over good governance: PM Dahal


[Nepal] - Three male rhinos in CNP moved internally


Nisikhola bus accident: death toll reaches nine, identity of all deceased ascertained


PM emphasizes the need to remain aware of climate change impacts on food security


[Nepal] - FALSE:: ERROR: UNSUPPORTED ENCODING


Japan, UNDP collaborate to advance climate smart agriculture, build resilient communities in Jajarkot


[Nepal] - FALSE:: ERROR: UNSUPPORTED ENCODING


Two killed in Myagdi jeep accident


[Nepal] - FALSE:: ERROR: UNSUPPORTED ENCODING


[Nepal] - FALSE:: ERROR: UNSUPPORTED ENCODING


[Nepal] - FALSE:: ERROR: UNSUPPORTED ENCODING


Gandaki province chief, Bhatta, assumes office


PM Dahal pledges support for Pokhara amp;#039;s development


Fire guts property worth around Rs 5 million


Local obstruction delays Nagdhunga Tunnel breakthrough by 14 meters


[Nepal] - Pokhara stated as Tourism Capital of Nepal


Prosperity through the use of technology, says Prime Minister Dahal


Earthquake recorded in Rasuwa


New power formula to alter the speed of government: PM Dahal


Fire in Morang rice mill causes loss of Rs 15M





13